Dinner Menu
Kid's Menu
Dessert Menu
Drink Menu
Click thumbnail to view menu.
Soup & Salads
Dressings available: Habanero Ranch | Bleu Cheese | Caesar | Balsamic Vinaigrette | Honey Mustard | Thousand Island | Chipotle Honey Vinaigrette | EVOO & Vinegar
Award Winning Mahi-Mahi Chowder
smoked corn | Idaho potatoes | local mahi-mahi | fresh vegetables | heavy cream | oyster crackers on the side | fresh herbs
Cup8
, Bowl12
Homemade Soup of the Day
ask your server about our soup of the day
-
Garden Salad
spring lettuce | red onions | grape tomatoes | cucumbers | shaved carrots | sunflowers seeds | your choice of dressing
11
Traditional Caesar Salad
crisp romaine lettuce | creamy Caesar dressing | garlic croutons | shaved parmesan cheese
11
Avocado Caprese
spring lettuce | fresh mozzarella | vine ripe tomatoes | fresh avocado slices | balsamic reduction | basil oil
12
Add to any salad or entree:
grilled chicken breast6
, fried oysters8
, fried or seared NC shrimp7
, seared scallopsMkt Price
, seared salmonMkt Price
, seared fresh fish of the dayMkt Price
Shareables
Fried Calamari
lightly breaded calamari rings & tentacles | creamy | lemon & caper sauce | fresh herbs | queso fresco
12
Buffalo Shrimp
lightly breaded then golden fried NC shrimp tossed in a homemade buffalo sauce | habanero ranch on the side
11
Buffalo Chicken Wings
chicken wings | homemade buffalo sauce | celery sticks | your choice of: habanero ranch or bleu cheese dressing
15
Chupe de Mejillones (Mussels)
fresh sauteed mussels | aji’s light cream | fresh herbs peppers | green onions | queso fresco | grilled garlic French bread
15
Philly Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
seared thinly sliced beef | spices | sauteéd onions & peppers | fresh mozzarella | chimichurri aioli dipping sauce
13
NC Crab Dip
a blend of crab | three kinds of cheese toasted | French bread | fresh herbs
15
Sides
Fresh Fruit
6
Mashed Potatoes
5
Cheddar Stone Grits
5
Spanish Rice
5
Pinto Beans
5
Sassy Slaw
5
Mixed Vegetables
6
Green Beans & Onions
6
Brussels
6
Corn & Sweet Peas
6
Side of French Fries
5
Basket of Seasoned French Fries
8
Handhelds
Gluten-free bread for $2 extra
The Flatbread
warm sweet potato flatbread | brie cheese spread | pickle onions | guava jam | fresh herbs
13
Chicken Sandwich
grilled chicken breast | smoked bacon| provolone cheese | fried onions | honey chipotle aioli | toasted brioche bun | lettuce | tomato | pickle spear | French fries
13
All-the-way Burger
cooked to order 7oz beef patty | cheddar | bacon | roasted garlic mayo | fried onions | toasted brioche bun lettuce | tomato | pickle spear | French fries
15
Mahi-Mahi Reuben
blackened Mahi-Mahi | sassy slaw | Swiss cheese | Thousand Island dressing | baked sourdough bread | pickle spear | French fries
17
Philly Cheesesteak
seared thinly sliced beef | sauteéd onions | sauteéd peppers | toasted sub roll | roasted garlic mayo | pickle spear | French fries | Your choice of: provolone or cheddar cheese
16
Main Course
Add a side Caesar salad to any entrée for $6
Shrimp Pasta
sauteéd NC shrimp | rotini pasta | squash | zucchini | mushrooms | onions | peppers | Peruvian tomato & aji broth | shaved parmesan | fresh herbs | grilled garlic French bread
23
Tacos Callejeros (Street Tacos)
lightly breaded fried fish the day | flour tortilla | cilantro cabbage slaw | queso fresco | avocado lime crema | Spanish rice & pinto beans
19
Fisherman’s Seafood Stew
local mahi-mahi | NC shrimp | fresh mussels | fresh corn | local vegetables | Idaho potatoes | traditional Peruvian broth | Spanish rice | fresh herbs | grilled garlic French bread
30
Bone-in Pork Chop
10 oz spice-rubbed grilled pork chop | mashed potatoes | green beans & onions | caramelized apple & onion puree | green apple & fennel salad
23
Fish & Chips
beer-battered Mahi - Mahi | French fries | sassy slaw | remoulade sauce
20
Fried Oysters
lightly breaded then golden fried local oysters | French fries | sassy slaw | remoulade sauce
24
Fried NC Shrimp
lightly breaded then golden fried local shrimp | French fries | sassy slaw | remoulade sauce
23
Build Your Own Fish of the Day
seared fish of the day (listed on the specials sheet) | served with your choice of two sides | remoulade sauce
Mkt Price
12 & under
Chicken Tender
choice of: French fries or fresh fruit
8
Fried Fish Basket
fish of the day with choice of: French fries or fresh fruit
8
Kid Cheeseburger
choice of: French fries or fresh fruit
9
Grilled Cheese
white bread & cheddar cheese with choice of: French fries or fresh fruit
8
Mac n Cheese
8
Bread Pudding
traditional Peruvian bread pudding | raisins | caramel sauce | vanilla ice cream | whipped cream | fresh mint
8
Hershey Bar Cake
Outer Banks favor | whipped cream | chocolate sauce | chocolate shavings | fresh mint
9
Old Fashioned Apple Crisp
brown sugar & old fashioned oats topping | vanilla ice cream | caramel sauce
8
Crème Brûlée
vanilla crème brûlée | fresh strawberry | whipped cream | fresh mint
9
Carrot Cake
caramel sauce | whipped cream | pecans | fresh mint
9
Ice Cream
choice of vanilla, chocolate ice cream or sorbet. (Ask your server about our daily sorbet flavor)
1 scoop3
, 2 scoops5
, 3 scoops7
Chef Specialty Dessert
Ask your server about our daily chef dessert
-
Martini Dessert for the Grown Ups
"Peanut Butter Cup" | peanut butter whiskey | vanilla vodka | chocolate liqueur | half & half
12
Daily Specials
Daily Drink Specials
Check Mahi Mahi's Facebook page for a list of our daily drink specials.
Varies