Tortugas "Greek" Salad

Tomatoes, red onion, red pepper, kalamata olive, cuke and feta cheese over mixed greens.
$9.50
,
Add Grilled Chicken$12.50
,
Add Garlic Shrimp$13.50

Salad Du Jour

Chef's choice.
Priced Daily--

Hatteras Style Chowder

Clear broth style clam chowder.
Cup$4.50

Homeboy's Whim

Chef's choice soup.
Priced Daily--

The Lie Salad

Crisp and cool.
$4.99

The Big Lie

Smoked turkey breast, crisp bacon and cheese.
$8.50

Grilled Fish

Subject to availability.
Priced Daily--

Crabcake Sandwich

Seasonal. Why? We use only fresh, local crab meat.
Priced Daily--

Hummus Wrap

Spicy housemade garbonzo spread, fresh tomatoes, roasted peppers and mixed greens in a cheddar jalapeno wrap.
$8.50

Bean and Rice Burrito

Traditional beans and rice stuffed in a cheddar jalapeno wrap with peppers, onions, jack cheese and BBQ sauce.
$7.50

Grilled Cheese

$5.50

Peanut Butter & Jelly

$4.99

Chicken Tenders

with French fries.
$7.25

Kids Buttered Pasta

$5.99

Big Wave Dave

Grilled chicken breast with fresh pineapple and Swiss cheese.
$8.99

BBQ Cluck

Honey habanero BBQ chicken breast with sliced apple and cheddar cheese.
$8.99

Carib Burger

With salsa and provolone cheese.
$8.75

Bajan Burger

Honey habanero BBQ burger with bacon and cheddar cheese.
$9.50

Swiss Jerk Burger

Covered with spicy jerk seasoning and Swiss cheese.
$8.75

Teriyaki Burger

Teriyaki glazed burger served with grilled pineapple and Swiss cheese.
$8.99

Garden Burger

Grilled meatless patty with honey habanero BBQ sauce, fresh tomatoes and mixed greens on whole wheat bread.
$7.99

Hamburger

$8.25

Cheeseburger

$8.50

Creole Crawdads

Tail meat sauteed with tomatoes, onion and garlic.
$8.99

Beans and Rice

$4.50

Cayman Conch Fritters

Loaded with conch and lightly fried.
$9.99

Bite of the Day

Spicy island marinade, lightly floured and fried.
$8.99

Nachos Supreme

The ultimate black bean nachos with all the works.
$8.50

Chips and Salsa

$2.59

Garlic Bread

$2.99

Island Fries

Side$2.75
,
Basket$3.99

White Garlic Pizza

Topped with artichoke hearts, fresh tomatoes, red onion, sweet red peppers and feta cheese.
$7.99
,
Add Shrimp$9.99

Chili Wings

Chili garlic glazed wings with chopped peanuts and scallions.
$8.99

Hummus

Spicy housemade garbonzo spread served with toasted pita points.
$7.50

Baja Fish Taco Platter

Two fish soft tacos stuffed with jack cheese, sliced cabbage and our housemade baja taco sauce. Sour cream and jalapenos served on the side.
$9.99

Grilled Fish and Black Bean Burrito

Daily fish stuffed in a cheddar jalapeno wrap with jack cheese, sauteed peppers, onions and black beans. Served with rice, salsa and sour cream.
$10.50

Jamaican Jerk Beef

Marinated and grilled, topped with spicy jerk seasoning.
$9.99

Jamaican Jerk Chicken

Choice of breast or leg and thigh, stuffed with our jerk seasoning. Served with a warm pineapple chutney.
$9.50

Saint Martin Shrimp

Served with onion, garlic and tomatoes over pasta.
$12.50

Coco Loco Chicken

Chicken breast rolled in coconut and cracked pepper, fried with lime curry dipping sauce.
$9.50

Alaskan Snow Crab Legs

Half Pound$10.99
,
Pound$18.99

Shrimp and Veggie Platter

With fresh grated Parmesan.
$12.99

Steamed Clams

Half Dozen$5.99
,
Dozen$8.99

Steamed Combo

Choose any two to four items to make your own combo.
$19.99

Steamed Spiced Shrimp

Half Pound$9.99
,
Pound$17.99

Steamed Veggie Platter

An array of fresh veggies topped with fresh grated Parmesan.
$6.99

Hatteras Style Chowder

Clear broth style clam chowder.
Cup$4.99
,
Bowl$6.50

Homeboy's Whim

Chef's choice soup.
Priced Daily--

Salad du Jour

Chef's choice.
Priced Daily--

The Lie Salad

Crisp and cool.
$4.99

Tortugas "Greek" Salad

Tomatoes, red onion, red peppers, kalamata olive, cuke and feta cheese over mixed greens.
$9.99
,
Add Grilled Chicken$12.99
,
Add Garlic Shrimp$13.99

BBQ Cluck

Honey habanero BBQ chicken breast with sliced apple and cheddar cheese.
$9.99

Bean and Rice Burritio

Traditional beans and rice stuffed in a cheddar jalapeno wrap with peppers, onions, jack cheese and BBQ sauce.
$7.99

Big Wave Dave

Grilled chicken breast with fresh pineapple and Swiss cheese.
$9.99

Chicken Tenders

Served with French fries.
$7.99

Crabcake Sandwich

Seasonal. Why? We use only fresh local crab meat.
Priced Daily--

Garden Burger

Grilled meatless patty with honey habanero BBQ sauce, fresh tomatoes and mixed greens on whole wheat bread.
$8.99

Grilled Cheese

$6.50

Grilled Fish

Subject to availability.
Priced Daily--

Hummus Wrap

Spicy housemade garbonzo spread, fresh tomatoes, roasted red peppers and mixed greens in a cheddar jalapeno wrap.
$9.50

Kids Buttered Pasta

$6.99

Peanut Butter and Jelly

$5.99

The Big Lie

Smoked turkey breast, crisp bacon and cheese.
$9.50

Bajan Burger

Honey habanero BBQ burger with bacon and cheddar cheese.
$10.50

Carib Burger

With salsa and provolone cheese.
$9.99

Cheeseburger

$9.50

Hamburger

$8.99

Swiss Jerk Burger

Covered with spicy jerk seasoning and Swiss cheese.
$9.99

Teriyaki Burger

Teriyaki glazed burger served with grilled pineapple and Swiss cheese.
$9.99

Beans and Rice

$4.99

Bite of the Day

Spicy island marinade, lightly floured and fried.
$9.50

Cayman Conch Fritters

Loaded with conch and lightly fried.
$10.99

Chili Wings

Chili garlic glazed wings with chopped peanuts and scallions.
$9.50

Chips and Salsa

$2.99

COCONUT CREAM PIE

Best on the Beach
--

Creole Crawdads

Tail meat sauteed with tomato, onion and garlic.
$9.50

Garlic Bread

$2.99

Hummus

Spicy housemade garbanzo spread served with toasted pita points.
$7.99

Island Fries

Side$2.99
,
Basket$4.50

Nachos Supreme

The ultimate black bean nachos with all the works - jack cheese, black beans, housemade salsa, sour cream, scallions and jalapenos. Ask your server about adding chicken or tuna!
$8.99

White Garlic Pizza

Topped with artichoke hearts, fresh tomatoes, red onion, sweet red peppers and feta cheese.
$8.50
,
Add Shrimp$10.99

Baja Fish Taco Platter

Two fish soft tacos stuffed with jack cheese, sliced cabbage and our housemade baja taco sauce. Served with sour cream and jalapenos on the side.
$13.50
,
Add an extra taco$17.50

Coco Loco Chicken

Chicken breast rolled in coconut and cracked pepper, fried and served with lime curry dipping sauce.
$11.99

Grilled Fish and Black Bean Burrito

Daily fish stuffed in a cheddar jalapeno wrap with jack cheese, sauteed peppers, onions and black beans. Served with rice, salsa and sour cream.
$11.99

Jamaican Jerk Beef

Marinated and grilled, topped with spicy jerk seasoning.
5 oz.$11.99
,
8 oz.$15.50

Alaskan Snow Crab Legs

1/2 lb.$10.99
,
1 lb.$18.99

Shrimp and Veggie Platter

Topped with fresh grated Parmesan.
$12.99

Steamed Clams

1/2 dozen$5.99
,
1 dozen$8.99

Steamed Combo

Choose any two to four items to make your own combo.
$19.99

Steamed Spiced Shrimp

1/2 lb.$9.99
,
1 lb.$17.99

Steamed Veggie Platter

An array of fresh veggies topped with fresh grated Parmesan.
$6.99

Island Steak

12 oz. dry rubbed chef's choice cut topped with a roasted garlic herb butter. Served with starch and vegetable of the day.
$23

Jamaican Jerk Chicken

Half chicken stuffed with our jerk seasoning. Served with traditional bean and rice.
$16.99

Pepper Steak

London broil coated in cracked peppers, grilled and served with garlic pepper cream sauce. Served with beans and rice.
$17.50

Pork Antonio

Two jerk rubbed pork chops finished with sweet and spicy habenero yellow currant jam. Served with starch and vegetable of the day.
$16.99

Skewered Shrimp Barbados

Thai chili glazed shrimp skewered with fresh pineapple, sweet pepper and red onion, topped with chopped peanuts. Served over traditional beans and rice.
$18.99

Tortola Chicken

Two grilled chicken breasts topped with roasted garlic and cracked pepper cream sauce. Served with traditional beans and rice.
$16.99

Creole Crawdad Fett

With onion, garlic, tomatoes and peppers over pasta.
$18.50

St. Martin Shrimp

A signature dish since we opened Tortugas’ Lie back in 1990 — pan sautéed onion, roasted garlic, tomato, bacon, and fresh North Carolina shrimp (in season), over fettuccine has been a favorite among locals for years.
$19.99

Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie

Freshly baked in house by our talented pastry chef!
$4.95

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Freshly baked in house by our talented pastry chef!
$4.95

Coconut Cream Pie

Freshly baked in house by our talented pastry chef!
$4.95

Key Lime Pie

Freshly baked in house by our talented pastry chef!
$4.95

Toasted Turtle

An after dinner coffee drink made with Frangelica, Baileys and fresh roasted coffee.
$6.50

Smoked Salmon

With marinated onion.
$7

Yellow Fin Tuna

$8

Battleship

Flying fish roe. Two per order.
$4

Eel

Two per order.
$4

Shrimp

Two per order.
$3.25

Smoked Salmon

Two per order.
$3.50

Yellow Fin Tuna

Two per order.
$3.99

California Roll

Crab stix, avocado, cream cheese and toasted sesame.
$6.25

Eel Roll

Cucumber, sesame and eel sauce.
$7

Rainbow Roll

Smoked salmon, tuna, avocado, cucumber and sesame seeds.
$8.50

Smoked Salmon Roll

Smoked salmon, cream cheese, marinated onion, cucumber and masago.
$7

Spicy Chili BBQ Shrimp Roll

Cilantro corn relish, white cabbage and sesame seeds.
$8

Tortuga Roll

Tuna, crispy wanton, chili, aoli and masago.
$7.50

Tuna and Cream Cheese

$6.25

Tuna Dynamite

$6.25

Tuna Roll

$7

Veggie Roll

Carrot, mixed green, sweet red pepper, avocado, cucumber and sesame.
$6

Fried Oyster Roll

Fried oysters, cucumbers, eel sauce and sesame seeds.
$8

Fryin' Hawaiian Roll

Tuna, cream cheese and golden pineapple deep fried with chili aoli.
$9

Hatteras Roll

Tuna, crab, cream cheese and sesame seeds.
$8

House Salad

With ginger dressing.
$2

Island Roll

No rice roll. Tuna, mango, cilantro and salmon.
$10

Rock and Roll

Asparagus, avocado, steamed shrimp and massago.
$8.50

Salmon Nigiri

$2

Seaweed Salad

With masago.
$4

Spider Roll

Local soft shells fried with marinated onion and masago.
$8

Super Veggie Roll

Mixed greens, cream cheese, fried wantons, corn salsa, carrots, cucumbers, avocados, onions, red peppers and sesame seeds.
$8

The Rasta Roll

Red pepper, mango, grilled asparagus and fresh salmon.
$9