We’re known here at New York Pizza Pub for our welcoming and spacious atmosphere, friendly staff and, yes, our pizza – which is hand-tossed with homemade sauces and such a huge selection of toppings that you could have fun creating 100 different variations, including ones with gluten-free crusts! But our Nags Head restaurant is also the place to come for a wide selection of the freshest local seafood, chicken, burgers and other sandwiches and Italian specialties. Our salads are great by themselves or as an add-on. And here’s a secret that locals and seasoned visitors will tell you: We serve the best steak on the beach – a hand-cut, wet-aged, 14 ounce Angus ribeye that’s grilled to perfection.

Take a look at our menus here. You’ll see that this Nags Head restaurant’s got you covered, no matter if you have a huge family whose members all want different things. And we take care of the little ones too – what self-respecting Italian restaurant doesn’t!

Buffalo Shrimp

Six fried local shrimp served with ranch.
8

Fried Mac & Cheese

Panko encrusted and served with marinara sauce.
9

Onion Ring Basket

Served with ranch.
8

Potato Skins

Six big wedges of potato loaded with cheddar, scallions, mozzarella and bacon, served with marinara sauce.
9

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

Served with marinara.
9

Garlic Knots

Fresh pizza dough baked with herbs and spices.
Half Dozen5
,
Dozen9

Buffalo Wings

Our famous jumbo chicken wings (8) tossed with your choice of: mild, hot, nuclear, honey BBQ, Asian or sweet heat sauce, served with your choice of bleu cheese or ranch and celery.
Small (8 pieces)11
,
Party Platter (30 pieces)33

Primo Sampler

Buffalo wings (4), fried mozzarella (4), potato skins (4), and garlic knots (4). Served with marinara sauce, ranch dressing and sour cream.
19
Dressing choices: ranch, bleu cheese, creamy Caesar, honey mustard, balsamic vinaigrette and Italian dressing. Add to salad: Grilled or Fried Chicken Breast | 6 Fried or Grilled Shrimp | 7 Homemade Meatballs | 6 Italian Sausage | 6

Insalate Della Casa (House Salad)

Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, croutons, red onions, mixed cheese, cucumbers and your choice of housemade dressing on the side.
7

Italian Cobb Salad

Mixed greens, cucumber, cherry tomatoes, pepperoncini, mixed cheese, croutons, kalamata olives, egg, bacon and your choice of housemade dressing on the side.
10

Classic Caesar

Fresh romaine tossed with Caesar dressing topped with croutons and Parmesan cheese.
7
All pasta served with toasted garlic bread. Add a side house or Caesar salad to any entree: 4.

Cheese Tortellini Rustica

Tortellini, mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, Italian sausage and scampi sauce topped with Parmesan cheese.
16

Four Cheese Ravioli

Six four-cheese ravioli tossed with our signature marinara sauce topped with Parmesan cheese.
16

Shrimp Scampi

Sauteed shrimp with spinach, cherry tomatoes, lemon, white wine, butter sauce and spaghetti pasta topped with Parmesan sauce.
18

Spaghetti and Meatballs

Three meatballs tossed with our signature marinara sauce and spaghetti topped with Parmesan cheese.
15

Chicken Parmigiana

Chicken breast cutlet, breaded and smothered with mozzarella and marinara served on top of spaghetti.
17

Lasagna

Homemade layers of pasta with Italian meats and cheese, topped with marinara sauce and Parmesan cheese.
16

Fettuccine Alfredo

Sauteed cherry tomatoes, scallions in a rich garlic Alfredo sauce over fettuccine with your choice of grilled chicken or sauteed shrimp topped with Parmesan cheese.
18

Penne Alla Vodka

Italian sausage, penne pasta tossed with sauteed shallots, cherry tomatoes, mushrooms, basil in vodka cream sauce topped with Parmesan cheese.
17
All sandwiches served with lettuce, tomato, pickle and french fries. Upgrade to onion rings for 1.50.

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Fried chicken breast cutlet baked with house marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
12

Chicken Sandwich

Fried or grilled chicken breast cutlet topped with provolone cheese, bacon, pesto mayo on a toasted brioche roll.
11

Hamburger

Grilled 8oz. hamburger served on a toasted brioche roll. Cheeses: cheddar, bleu cheese crumbles, provolone, or American
10
,
Add Raw or Sauteed Onions1.50 each
,
Add Bacon2
,
Add Fried Egg0.75

Meatball Sub

Homemade meatballs in a toasted sub roll with marinara and provolone cheese.
11

NYPP Burger

Grilled 8oz. hamburger topped with marinara sauce, melted mozzarella cheese, bacon and fried onion rings served on a toasted brioche roll.
14

Philly Cheese Steak

Ribeye Philly steak, sauteed onions and peppers, provolone cheese in a toasted sub roll.
12

Calzone

Our homemade pizza dough filled with creamy ricotta cheese, mozzarella and spices. Choose any three toppings to add: extra cheese, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, red onions, bacon, ground beef, ham, pineapple, black olives, green olives, anchovies, banana peppers, jalapeno peppers, cherry tomatoes, spinach, fresh mozzarella, artichokes and sundried tomatoes.
With Your Choice of 3 Fillings14
Every pizza is hand-tossed to order and baked in our brick ovens. They are then topped with the highest quality ingredients. This is real New York pizza and your can't rush perfection! No substitutions. Half topping extra charge.

Supreme

Ground beef, pepperoni, sausage, peppers, mushroom, onion and extra cheese.
14"22
,
16"24

Veggie Lovers

Fresh peppers, onions, spinach, garlic, mozzarella, mushrooms and sliced tomatoes.
14"22
,
16"24

Meatza Pizza

Ground beef, ham, pepperoni, sausage and plenty of mozzarella.
14"22
,
16"24

Grilled Chicken Pesto

Fresh basil pesto sauce, sliced tomatoes, provolone, romano, mozzarella, sundried tomatoes and grilled chicken breast. No pizza sauce.
14"22
,
16"24

Mediterranean

Sliced tomatoes, spinach, onion, garlic, mozzarella, olive and feta. No pizza sauce.
14"22
,
16"24

Mulberry Street

Mozzarella, romano, sliced tomatoes, crispy bacon and fresh garlic.
14"20
,
16"22

Spinach Romano

Fresh spinach, romano, mozzarella, pizza sauce and ricotta.
14"20
,
16"22

Bacon Double Cheeseburger

Ground beef, mozzarella, crispy bacon and cheddar.
14"20
,
16"22

Four Cheese

Smothered with romano, provolone, mozzarella and cheddar.
14"20
,
16"22

Superoni

Double cheese and double pepperoni.
14"20
,
16"22

Hawaiian Sunset

Ham, Hawaiian pineapple and plenty of mozzarella.
14"20
,
16"22

Bianco

Creamy ricotta, spinach, mozzarella, and a touch of garlic. No pizza sauce.
14"20
,
16"22

Create Your Own

The classic New York original with a hand-tossed crust. Toppings: extra cheese, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, bacon, ground beef, fresh garlic, spinach, ham, olives, sliced tomato, anchovies, feta, pineapple, fried eggplant, banana peppers, cheddar, sundried tomatoes, and hot cherry peppers. Premium Toppings: grilled, fried, or BBQ chicken breast; bay scallops; or shrimp.
14"15
,
16"17
,
Gluten Free (10")14
,
Toppings on Half1.50 each
,
Toppings on Whole2 each
,
Premium Toppings on Half4 each
,
Premium Toppings on Whole6 each
For ages 10 and younger. Soft drink included.

Kid's Cheeseburger

Served with fries.
8

Kid's Grilled Cheese

Served with fries.
7

Kid's Pasta

Choice of plain, buttered, Alfredo or marinara sauce.
8
,
Add a Meatball2

Kid's Chicken Tenders

Served with fries.
8

Kid's Pizza

Choice of one topping.
9

Veggie of the Day

3

Extra Dressing

.50

Meatballs

Three homemade meatballs.
6

Italian Sausage

5

French Fries

3

Onion Rings

5

Mashed Potatos

3