We’re known here at New York Pizza Pub for our welcoming and spacious atmosphere, friendly staff and, yes, our pizza – which is hand-tossed with homemade sauces and such a huge selection of toppings that you could have fun creating 100 different variations, including ones with gluten-free crusts! But our Nags Head restaurant is also the place to come for a wide selection of the freshest local seafood, chicken, burgers and other sandwiches and Italian specialties. Our salads are great by themselves or as an add-on. And here’s a secret that locals and seasoned visitors will tell you: We serve the best steak on the beach – a hand-cut, wet-aged, 14 ounce Angus ribeye that’s grilled to perfection.

We make all our marsala, sauces and stocks from scratch, and because we are a true Italian family, we honestly do use Grandma’s (aka Nona’s) tested and perfected recipes. We’re proud of our heritage that honors great food served in an atmosphere where you’re expected to take your time and savor your meal.

Take a look at our menus here. You’ll see that this Nags Head restaurant’s got you covered, no matter if you have a huge family whose members all want different things. And we take care of the little ones too – what self-respecting Italian restaurant doesn’t!

 

Potato Skins

Big wedges of potato loaded with cheddar, scallions, mozzarella and bacon.
Small8.49
,
Large14.99

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

Served with marinara.
7.99

Garlic Knots

Fresh pizza dough baked with herbs and spices.
Half Dozen3.99
,
Dozen7.49

Tuna Bites

Breaded and fried or grilled plain or blackened.
10.99

Chicken Tenders

Served with honey mustard.
7.99

Buffalo Wings

Our famous jumbo chicken wings in our spicy cayenne sauce available in mild, medium, nuclear, honey BBQ or sweet heat sauce. Served with bleu cheese or ranch and celery.
Small (8 pieces)9.49
,
Medium (16 pieces)17.49
,
Party Platter (30 pieces)29.99

Fried Calamari

Served with marinara.
9.99

Primo Sampler

Buffalo wings, fried mozzarella, potato skins, and garlic knots. Served with marinara sauce.
Small10.99
,
Large19.99
Dressing choices: homemade creamy balsamic, bleu cheese, ranch, Greek, Caesar, 1000 island or honey mustard.

Tossed Garden Salad

Fresh mixed lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers and onions.
Small3.99
,
Large7.49
,
Add Grilled Chicken+4.99
,
Add Shrimp+8.99
,
Add Tuna+8.99

Greek Salad

Crispy mixed lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, kalamata olives, onions, pepperoncini and feta. Served with Greek dressing.
11.99
,
Add Grilled Chicken+4.99
,
Add Shrimp+8.99
,
Add Tuna+8.99

Caesar Salad

Fresh, crispy romaine, tossed with croutons, grated pecorino romano and Caesar dressing.
Small3.99
,
Large7.49

Grilled Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken breast over mixed greens, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, cucumbers and crispy bacon.
12.99
,
Sub Tuna or Shrimp+3.99
Served with your choice of baked potato, french fries, or pasta, and vegetable of the day.

Hand Cut Angus Ribeye Steaks

Our grilled 14-oz. boneless steaks, thick and juicy.
Simply Grilled24.99
,
Bourbon Teriyaki26.99
,
Smothered Mushrooms and Onions26.99

Chicken Parmigiana

Chicken breast cutlet, breaded and smothered with mozzarella and marinara.
17.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

Eggplant cutlets, smothered with mozzarella and marinara.
17.99

Seared Tuna

Local tuna steak, seared or blackened on your request.
20.99

Shrimp Parmigiana

Jumbo shrimp, breaded and smothered with mozzarella and marinara.
21.99

Fried Shrimp

Tender, jumbo butterflied shrimp, lightly breaded.
20.49

Shrimp & Strips Basket

Fried popcorn shrimp and tender clam strips, with french fries.
15.99

Fish Special

Fish Special varies depending on the Catch of the Day and seasonal veggies. Pictured is garlic pepper seared tuna over a bed of sundried tomato golden rice topped with fennel salad.
-

Lasagna

A big slice of our three-layered masterpiece. Not recommended for small appetites.
15.99

Fettuccine Alfredo

Our romano cream sauce over imported fettuccine.
15.99
,
Add Grilled Chicken+4.99
,
Add Sautéed Shrimp+8.99

Penne Alla Vodka

Imported pasta covered with a pink vodka sauce.
15.99

Baked Ziti

Ziti pasta topped with tomato marinara and mozzarella.
14.99

Baked Ziti Siciliana

Ziti pasta in a creamy ricotta sauce topped with tomato marinara and fried eggplant strips.
16.99

Lobster Alfredo

A NYPP favorite! Pink alfredo sauce with fresh mushroom, diced tomatoes, garlic and lobster over penne pasta.
20.99

Ravioli Parmigiana

Tender ricotta cheese ravioli, smothered with mozzarella and marinara.
15.49

Tour of Italy

A generous plate for the hearty appetite featuring our lasagna, fettuccine alfredo and chicken parmigiana.
19.99

Pasta Your Way

Your choice of pasta (spaghetti, penne, fettuccine, or ravioli) combined with any of our homemade sauces.
Marinara12.99
,
Meat Sauce15.99
,
Pesto15.99
,
Add Sausage+4.49
,
Add Meatballs+3.99
Served with fries and pickle. To substitute onion rings, add $1.49.

8 oz. Tuna Steak

Served on a roll.
12.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Served on a roll.
9.99

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Fried chicken, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.
10.99

Turkey Club Wrap

Sliced turkey breast, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato and pesto mayo.
10.99

Arthur Avenue Wrap

Chicken cutlet, provolone cheese, roasted red peppers, baby spinach and our pesto mayo.
10.99

Calzone

Our homemade pizza dough filled with creamy ricotta cheese, mozzarella and spices. Choose any three toppings to add: extra cheese, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, bacon, ground beef, fresh garlic, spinach, ham, olives, sliced tomato, anchovies, feta, pineapple, fried eggplant, banana peppers, cheddar, sundried tomatoes, and hot cherry peppers. Premium toppings include: grilled, fried or BBQ chicken; bay scallops; or shrimp.
With up to three toppings13.49
,
Premium Toppings1.00 each
Served with fries and pickle. To substitute onion rings, add $1.49.

Chicken Parmigiana

11.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

11.99

Meatball Parmigiana

11.99

Philly Cheese Steak

Served with onions and yellow American, provolone or mozzarella.
11.99
100% Angus beef served with fries, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle on the side. To substitute onion rings, add $1.49.

The Bronx Burger

8-oz. of all-Angus ground beef, grilled over an open flame.
10.99
,
With Cheese11.49
,
With bacon and cheese11.99
,
With sautéed mushrooms & cheese12.49

NY Pizza Burger

8-oz. of all-Angus ground beef, grilled over an open flame topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
11.49
Every pizza is handtossed to order and baked in our brick ovens. They are then topped with the highest quality ingredients. This is real New York pizza and your can't rush perfection!

Supreme

Ground beef, pepperoni, sausage, peppers, mushroom, onion and extra cheese.
14"22.99
,
16"24.99

Vegetable

Fresh peppers, onions, spinach, garlic, mozzarella, mushrooms and sliced tomatoes.
14"22.99
,
16"24.99

Meatza Pizza

Ground beef, ham, pepperoni, sausage and plenty of mozzarella.
14"22.99
,
16"24.99

Seafood Alfredo

Bay scallops, shrimp, sliced tomato, garlic, scallion and mozzarella. No pizza sauce.
14"22.99
,
16"24.99

Buffalo Chicken

Buffalo chicken with our secret sauce, cheddar, mozzarella, scallions and a ranch drizzle. No pizza sauce.
14"22.99
,
16"24.99

Grilled Chicken Pesto

Fresh basil pesto sauce, sliced tomatoes, provolone, romano, mozzarella, sundried tomatoes and grilled chicken breast. No pizza sauce.
14"22.99
,
16"24.99

Mediterranean

Sliced tomatoes, spinach, onion, garlic, mozzarella, olive and feta. No pizza sauce.
14"22.99
,
16"24.99

Mulberry Street

Mozzarella, romano, sliced tomatoes, crispy bacon, fresh garlic and pizza sauce.
14"20.99
,
16"22.99

Spinach Romano

Fresh spinach, romano, mozzarella, pizza sauce and ricotta.
14"20.99
,
16"22.99

Bacon Double Cheeseburger

Ground beef, mozzarella, crispy bacon and cheddar.
14"20.99
,
16"22.99

Four Cheese

Smothered with romano, provolone, mozzarella and cheddar.
14"20.99
,
16"22.99

Superoni

Double cheese and double pepperoni.
14"20.99
,
16"22.99

Hawaiian Sunset

Ham, Hawaiian pineapple and plenty of mozzarella.
14"20.99
,
16"22.99

Bianco

Creamy ricotta, spinach, mozzarella, and a touch of garlic. No pizza sauce.
14"20.99
,
16"22.99

Create Your Own

The classic New York original with a hand-tossed crust. Toppings: extra cheese, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, bacon, ground beef, fresh garlic, spinach, ham, olives, sliced tomato, anchovies, feta, pineapple, fried eggplant, banana peppers, cheddar, sundried tomatoes, and hot cherry peppers. Premium Toppings: grilled, fried, or BBQ chicken breast; bay scallops; or shrimp.
14"$14.49
,
16"$16.49
,
Gluten Free (10")$12.99
,
Toppings on Half$1.39 each
,
Toppings on Whole$2.19 each
,
Premium Toppings on Half$3.99 each
,
Premium Toppings on Whole$5.99 each
For ages 10 and younger. Soft drink included.

Spaghetti with One Meatball

7.49

Chicken Tenders with Fries

7.49

Ravioli with One Meatball

7.49

Kid's Pizza

Choice of one topping.
7.49

Chicken Parmigiana & Spaghetti

8.49

Veggie of the Day

4.99

Ranch or Bleu Cheese Dressing

1.79

Meatballs

4.49

Italian Sausage

4.99

French Fries

4.49

Onion Rings

5.49

Baked Potato

4.49

Soft Drinks

With One Refill2.59

Bottled Water

1.89

Smoothies

Without alcohol. Your choice of strawberry, peach, banana, pina colada, and strawberry colada.
6.99
Enjoy the same fine food we prepare for our restaurant patrons, but take it home and feed the masses! Give us a call at least 3 hours in advance and we’ll gladly have everything ready for you to pick up. We have a large variety of custom trays available.

Italian Sausage

43.99

Primo Platter

Mozzarella sticks, potato skins, buffalo wings and garlic knots.
27.99

Buffalo or Honey BBQ Wings

Mild, medium, or nuclear, served with bleu cheese dressing.
29.99

Potato Skins

Big wedges of potato loaded with cheddar, mozzarella & bacon.
20.99

Garlic Knots

Fresh pizza dough baked with herbs and spices. House specialty!
19.99

Meatballs

Served in marinara sauce.
38.99

Garden

Fresh mixed lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers & onions.
26.99

Greek

Crispy mixed lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, kalamata olives, onions, pepperoncini, and feta served with homemade Greek dressing.
38.99

Caesar Salad

Fresh, crispy romaine, tossed with croutons, grated pecorino romano, and Caesar dressing.
28.99

Penne ala Vodka

Thick imported pasta covered with a pink vodka sauce.
45.99

Lasagna

Our three-layered masterpiece!
65.99

Chicken Parmigiana

Chicken breast cutlet, breaded and smothered with mozzarella & marinara.
67.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

Eggplant cutlets, smothered with mozzarella & marinara sauce.
59.99

Sausage & Peppers

Sweet Italian sausage, sauteed with fresh bell peppers, onions, and tomato sauce over fettuccine.
58.99

Baked Ziti

Tender ziti pasta in a creamy ricotta sauce topped with tomato marinara and fried eggplant strips.
41.99

Spaghetti Marinara

35.99