From the Sea

Includes crab legs, Seattle Dungeness Crab, local blue crabs, lobster tail, lobster claws, steamed spiced shrimp, bang-bang shrimp, popcorn shrimp, coconut curry shrimp, steamed mussels, steamed crawfish, steamed scallops, baked mahi mahi, local rockfish (when available), key lime marinated swordfish, local grouper, local cobia, fried oysters, crab cakes, crab dip, lobster mac and cheese, mushrooms stuffed with crab, clams casino, oysters rockafellow, glazed Asian salmon and so much more!
Adult Dinner Buffet$35.99
,
Kids 4 -12Their age + $5
,
Teens 13-15$29.99

From the Garden

Fried squash, fried okra, corn on the cob, steamed broccoli, baked potatoes, sauteed mushrooms, cucumber salad, creamed spinach, eggroll in a bowl, pickled beets, fresh green beans, broccoli, casserole, fresh salad bar and homemade dressings.
Adult Dinner Buffet$35.99
,
Kids 4 -12Their age + $5
,
Teens 13-15$29.99
,
Children 3 and YoungerFree with a Drink

From the Islands

Pineapple-glazed ham, local steaks, N.C. barbecue, corn dog nuggets, barbecue chicken, mac and cheese, St. Louis-style barbecue ribs, fried chicken, chicken tenders, Jamaican jerk chicken, onion rings, spaghetti with marinara sauce, cheese sticks, twice-baked potatoes, garlic mashed potatoes, rice, Thai curry rice, sweet potato waffle fries.
Adult Dinner Buffet$35.99
,
Kids 4-12Their age + $5
,
Teens 13-15$29.99
,
Children 3 and YoungerFree with a Drink

Homemade Soups & Breads

Creamy Crab Bisque, New England Clam Chowder, Fresh Dinner Rolls, Hush Puppies, Toast Points, King Hawaiian Rolls.
Adult Dinner Buffet$35.99
,
Kids 4 -12Their age + $5
,
Teens 13-15$29.99
,
Children 3 and YoungerFree with a Drink

Desserts

Florida Key Lime Pie, chocolate peanut butter pie, chocolate chip cookies, warm summer peach cobbler, grandma's apple pie, soft-serve ice cream, chocolate cake, New York cheesecake, hot apple crisp, sugar cookies, warm blueberry dump cake, banana pudding, fresh local seasonal fruits, coconut caramel cake.
Adult Dinner Buffet$35.99
,
Kids 4 -12Their age + $5
,
Teens 13-15$29.99
,
Children 3 and YoungerFree with a Drink
Also available for carry-out.

Soup - Carry Out

Choose from soups: She Crab Bisque (made with local blue crab meat), NE Clam Chowder
$9.99

Asian Grilled Wild Caught Ahi Tuna Salad

Served over our house salad, mandarin oranges, crispy noodles, sunflower seeds and Asian Ginger dressing.
$17.99

Grilled Steak Salad

Angus sirloin steak seared and sliced atop our house salad, dried cranberries, crispy noodles and chunky blue cheese dressing.
$17.99

Crabby Salad

One large, hand-pattied crab cake fried golden brown. Placed on a bed of crispy greens and served with your choice of homemade salad dressing.
$15.99

Seafood Salad

Choose your fried seafood to place on our house salad and top it with your favorite dressing. (Shrimp, oysters, clam strips, calamari.)
$15.99

House Salad

Sustainably grown crisp spring mix, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots and croutons. Dressings: Asian Ginger, buttermilk ranch, blue cheese or Italian.
$9.99
Also available for carry-out.

Jimmy's Burger

Fresh 1/2 lb. burger, served on a bun with a blend of cheddar and mozzarella cheese, fries and hushpuppies.
$13.99

Pork BBQ Sandwich

Succulent N.C. barbecue loaded on a bun and served with fries and hushpuppies.
$11.99

Impossible Burger

Plant-based burger nestled atop of lettuce, tomatoes and onions on a multi-grain bun with vegan cheese, spicy mustard and served with fries and a house salad.
$13.99

Crab Cake Sandwich

Loaded with blue crab meat and served with fries and hushpuppies.
$12.99

Jimmy's Po'Boy

Pick oysters, shrimp or clams strips - stuffed in a bun with fries and hushpuppies.
$12.99

Fried Chicken Sandwich

Chicken breast served on a bun with fries and hushpuppies.
$11.99

Fried Flounder Sandwich

Flaky local flounder served with fries and hushpuppies.
$12.99

Clambake Bucket to Go - Our Recommendation

The Clambake Bucket is a combination of shellfish, potatoes, onions and corn on the cob in a specially designed bucket: yours to keep! Just add liquid, put on the stove, cook for 30 minutes!
Market Price

Steamed Style - Hot & Delicious To Go!

Your favorite shellfish steamed up hot for you on a take-out buffet pan. Served with fries, coleslaw, and hushpuppies.
Market Price

Beach Bucket

2 Clusters of Alaskan King Snow Crab legs; 1 lb. of steamed, spiced shrimp; 1 dozen clams, 1 dozen mussels.
2 People$49.99
,
Add 2 Lobster Tails$14

Legs & Shrimp Bucket

6 Clusters of Alaskan King Snow Crab lets; 2 lb. of steamed, spiced shrimp
3-4 People$104.99

Ultimate Bucket

4 Lobster Tails, 4 clusters of Alaskan King Snow Crab legs, 1 lb. spiced, steamed shrimp, 1 dozen clams, 1 dozen mussels
3-4 People$104.99

Bucket of Legs

12 Clusters of the meatiest Alaskan King Snow crabs you will find!
3-4 People$159.99

Create Your Own Bucket

Add any and all shellfish - any combination you want! Choose from our “Fresh from the Steamer” menu.
*Set-Up Charge$9.99
,
Lobster Tail (One or Two)$9.99-14.99
,
Crab Legs$24.99
,
Clams$7.99
,
Crawfish$10.99
,
Mussels$7.99
,
Steamed Spiced Shrimp$16.99
,
Whole Lobster$19.99
,
Steamed Scallops$19.99

Fried Seafood Platters - Carry Out

Fried Crab Cakes$18.99
,
Fried Clam Strips$14.99
,
Fried Flounder$18.99
,
Fried Oysters$18.99
,
Fried Shrimp$16.99
,
Fried Seafood Combo$34.99

Fresh From the Steamer - Carry Out

Steamed Combo (1 — 2 people): 1 lobster tail, 1 cluster of crab legs, 1/2 lb. steamed, spiced shrimp, 1 doz. clams, 1 doz. mussels, 1 stone claw for $49.99 • Add or create your own Steamer with any of the following:
$49.99
,
Lobster Tail$9.99
,
2 Clusters of Snow Crab Legs$24.99
,
Clams$9.99
,
Mussels$9.99
,
Steamed Spiced Shrimp (1 lb)$18.99
,
Whole Lobster$21.99
,
Steamed Scallops$21.99
,
Blue Crabs (when available)Market Price

Dinners for Two - Carry Out

Perfect portions for two! Choose from any of the following: Four clusters of crab legs, plus 1 lb. steamed, spiced shrimp 2 lobster tails, 2 clusters of crab legs, 1 lb. steamed, spiced shrimp 2 steaks (12 oz.), 2 clusters of crab legs, 1 lb. of steamed, spiced shrimp 2 whole lobsters, 2 clusters of crab legs, plus 1 lb. of steamed, spiced shrimp
Crab & Shrimp Dinner$63.99
,
Lobster tails, Crab & Shrimp$59.99
,
Steak, Crab Legs & Shrimp$79.99
,
Whole lobster, Crab & Shrimp$69.99

Appetizers - Carry Out

Fried Okra, Onion Rings, Basket of Fries, Cheese Sticks, Tater Tots, Chicken Tenders, Stuffed Mushrooms, Sweet Potato Waffle Fries, Fried Calamari.
$8.99 - $11.99

Kids - Carry Out

Buttery Noodles • Clam Strips • Chicken Tenders • Corn Dog Nuggets • Fried Chicken Legs • Mac & Cheese • Popcorn Shrimp • Steak
$8.99

Monday & Fridays Free Lobster Tail

Free Lobster Tail all night long with purchase of an adult buffet on Mondays & Fridays. *Must print coupon (www.nagsheadguide.com/jimmysseafoodbuffet/coupons) and present to server. Cannot be used with any other offer
.

Tuesday & Thursday Lobster Love

All you can eat lobster claws on the buffet! Tuesdays & Thursdays ONLY. No coupon necessary
.

All You Can Eat Lobster Saturdays

All you can eat whole lobster for $29.99. Includes unlimited lobsters, fries, slaw & hush puppies. If you would like to add the buffet with the crab legs, soups, salads, desserts and the 100 other items, it is just an additional $10. Saturdays only
Lobster$29.99
,
Add Buffett$10.00

Chicken Tender Dinner

Served with fries and hushpuppies.
$13.99

Fried Clam Strip Dinner

Served with fries, slaw and hushpuppies.
$14.99

Fried Coconut Shrimp

Perfectly coated crispy coconut shrimp, served with fries and hushpuppies.
$15.99

Fried Crab Cake Dinner

2 large crab cakes with house salad, fries and hushpuppies.
$21.99

Fried Flounder

2 large pieces of flounder served with house salad, fries and hushpuppies.
$19.99

Fried Oyster Dinner

Served with fries, slaw and hushpuppies
$16.99

Gluten-Free Chicken Nuggets or Vegan Chicken Nuggets

Can substitute house salad for fries and hushpuppies.
$14.99

Jimmy's Sirloin Steak

12-ounce steak cooked to desired temperature. Served with a house salad, baked potato and hushpuppies.
$24.99

Popcorn Shrimp Dinner

Served with fries, slaw, hushpuppies.
$14.99

Pork BBQ Platter

North Carolina barbecue piled up and served with fries, slaw and hushpuppies.
$15.99

Steamed Mussels

Served with melted butter and a house salad.
$15.99

Steamed, Old Bay-Spiced Shrimp

Wild-caught large shrimp, served with house salad.
$21.99

Surf & Turf

Large-cut grass-fed Angus beef and 1/2 lb. of steamed shrimp, served with a house salad, baked potato and hushpuppies.
$29.99